Idle No More: A movement for change

Misha Noble-Hearle - January 18, 2013

An Idle No More participant at the Canadian embassy in Washington, D.C. (Jonathan Reed photo, used under Creative Commons license)
An Idle No More participant at the Canadian embassy in Washington, D.C. (Jonathan Reed photo, used under Creative Commons license)

Thirty years ago, Patricia Doyle-Bedwell sat in Dalhousie’s Student Union building with four other aboriginal students discussing issues such as class, racism and indigenous rights. She would never have guessed that 30 years later, more than 400 people would be packed into the Scotiabank Auditorium in support of, or simply eager to learn about, the same issues.

“I am overwhelmed with joy for the support of Idle No More,” says the Dalhousie professor and director of the Transition Year Program, speaking about the teach-in event held on campus last week.

Growth of a movement


Idle No More is a grassroots movement that began as an email exchange between four aboriginal activists in Saskatchewan last fall. Their discussions focused on Bill C-45, a 400-page bill passed in December 2012 by the Canadian government that made changes to the Indian Act, the Navigation Protection Act and the Environment Assessment Act, among others.

Worried how these changes would affect them and their treaty rights, the activists organized a rally in Saskatoon peacefully protesting the bill. Since then, the movement has caught fire, spreading rapidly and prominently around the country.

With live tweets during events and more than 75,000 "likes" on Facebook, Idle No More is powered by social media as well as the inaccuracies of mainstream media, says Howard Ramos, a faculty member in the Department of Sociology and Social Anthropology and an expert in Canadian Aboriginal mobilization and issues of ethnicity and race.

“The movement spread not just through social media, but when the media got it wrong,” says Dr. Ramos.

Often, Idle No More has been portrayed in affiliation with Attawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence’s hunger strike. After declaring that her First Nations band in Northern Ontario was in a state of emergency due to severe economic issues, she began a liquids-only diet on Dec. 11, 2012, demanding a meeting with Stephen Harper and Governor-General David Johnston. This media coverage sparked interest in Idle No More, merging the two separate movements, but Idle No More is about a lot more than one hunger strike.

The protection of Aboriginal Rights and environmental concerns are high on the to-do list of Idle No More organizers and supporters, but the movement also provides a platform for social learning and “unlearning,” an idea that Erin Wunker, English professor, explained at the January 8 event. She defined unlearning as the act of acknowledging something we thought was true as not being the truth.

“I am part of a population that has learned that I have always had a right to be here, and that is untrue,” said Wunker, identifying herself as a descendant of European-Canadian settlers. “We need to learn each other’s stories and unlearn the dominant discourse of them.”

Sparking a dialogue


Idle No More promotes education about issues that affect not only Aboriginal Canadians, but all Canadians, say those who are following it closely.

“The issues resonate with non-Aboriginal Canadians who also feel a lot of policies have been rammed in their faces without consultation,” says Dr. Ramos, identifying the cancellation of the long-form census, changes to Employment Insurance and changes to immigration policies.

That said, if 30 years ago Prof. Doyle-Bedwell and her peers were discussing similar issues that Idle No More is protesting against today, does the movement have any hope for real change? She says yes.

“Idle No More is the beginning of a process where we could actually have true representative and responsible government in Canada,” says Prof. Doyle-Bedwell. “We have to stand up so that we can tell our grandchildren and great-grandchildren that we stood up.”

Readers Say

thank you for covering this very important story. Thanks for including me. Idle no more focuses, IMHO, on the issues of consultation, the infringement of our Treaty and Aboriginal rights, and the environment. What do people think about their MP's voting for the removal of environmental protection on many of our lakes and waterways? Is this something people want? To me, personally, the process brings into question the democratic process. Who do the MPs work for?
I agree that Harper's omnibus bills, such as C-45, are an affront to democracy and do not allow for proper discussion and consultation. I feel though that the 'Idle No More' movement has gotten off-track, in no small part due to Chief Spence (who, if I understand correctly, appointed her common-law partner to a position that pays him $850 per day which, if true, is a blatant conflict of interest and a slap in the face to those in need in her community). Lawyer Jeffery Rath's 'Show us the money' article in the Globe and Mail bordered on the offensive, as he essentially stated that taxpayers have no business whatsoever questioning where any funds allocated for First Nations people go and the government should simply fork over more money with no effort to determine whether that would solve the problems facing many of Canada's First Nations peoples. I think a legitimate discussion needs to take place to determine a way forward, and it would be helpful, IMO, if the focus of 'Idle No More' could be turned back to environmental/treaty issues and how First Nations peoples and the government can work together to make positive change and not just continue with the status quo.

The teach-in discussed in this article was presented by Solidarity Halifax in collaboration with local organizers of Idle No More events.

Videos of the teach-in and other resources about Idle No More are available at:
http://solidarityhalifax.ca/campaigns/indigenous-solidarity/
Hi. I teacher in Mishkeegogamang First Nation in Northwestern Ontario. I have been an environmental and social activist my whole adult life and am very pleased to see this Idle No More group standing up for our country. Mish is a little off the beaten track, so it's difficult to get very involved. If we could have a few members of the group come and talk to us here it would be great.

Thanks.

Sandra Austin,
Teacher at Missabay Community School, Mishkeegogamang, Ontario.
Chief Spence's greed and legitimate issues should be separate.

Join the conversation, but keep it clean, stay on the topic and be brief. Read comments policy.

Characters remaining: 2000

(optional)