Dalhousie faces transit strike

University puts contingencies in place, encourages carpooling

Ryan McNutt - February 1, 2012

A student waits for the bus on LeMarchant Street. (Bruce Bottomley photo)
A student waits for the bus on LeMarchant Street. (Bruce Bottomley photo)

Updated: February 2, 1:33 p.m.

Halifax is facing its first transit strike in 14 years.

At the 11th hour, talks broke off between the Halifax Regional Municipality and the union which represents bus operators, ferry crews, fleet mechanics and others. The workers official went on strike shortly after 1:30 a.m. on Thursday, Feb. 2.

The last transit strike in Halifax took place during the summer months—when many students were away from campus—and was well before the introduction of the UPass program. Today, a transit strike could have a dramatic impact on the Dal community.

Read also: Dalhousie transit strike information

“I’m pretty reliant on Metro Transit,” says Alexina Dubois, a first-year arts student. “I don’t have a car and my mom works during the day so I really don’t know what I would do.”

“Just over 21 per cent of Dal students use public transit as their main form of transportation to campus,” says Rochelle Owen, who as director of sustainability conducts a yearly transportation demand survey. “That’s about 3,500 students who will be most affected by a strike.”

In addition, 21 per cent of employees (approximately 1,000) use public transit as their primary way of getting to campus.

Carpooling will be key


Since last week, when a transit strike first looked like a strong possibility, leaders across the university have been planning contingencies.

“We have a lot of people who will be directly affected by this,” explains Ken Burt, vice-president finance and administration. “And the indirect impacts could be just as significant – if congested traffic makes it difficult to get to campus, that will cause strain on classes, on operations and more.”

The most important thing the Dal community can do to help, says Mr. Burt, is to offer drives to those affected by the strike, or to partner with other drivers to carpool and help ease the traffic situation.

The university has made several different tools available to help connect students and employees looking to carpool. These include MyDal’s classifieds (search under “Rides”) and the HRM Smart Trip program, where you can search for drives by postal code and can connect with Dal people as well as ride seekers from other Halifax organizations. There’s also a “Dalhousie Ride Sharing” Facebook group and a Twitter hashtag—#DalRides—that people can use to find or offer drives.

To encourage carpooling, the university will be making the Hancock lot (corner of Oxford and Coburg) during peak hours — 7 a.m. until 9:30 a.m. Vehicles must have a Dal parking pass and three people or more (two plus the driver) to park there during that time. Dal Security will also be allowing drivers with a reserved pass to the Dunn lot to trade those passes between vehicles during the strike so they can join with other drivers and carpool.

And while most of Dalhousie’s reserved parking lots are at or near capacity, Dal Security says that there are still spots available at Fenwick Towers that can be purchased at a pro-rated price for the remainder of the parking year (until September). Contact Security at 494-6400 for more information.

Class considerations


With thousands of students affected by a transit strike, professors and lecturers are being encouraged to do everything they can to minimize the impact on the academic term. All classes, labs and tutorials will continue during the strike.

“We’re asking our faculty members and instructors to be considerate of the circumstances, and to discuss with students their contingency plans for how their courses will be affected by a transit strike,” says Carolyn Watters, vice-president academic and provost.

Some of the potential contingencies that students may see implemented in their classes include adjustments to attendance/participation policies and exploring online delivery of some classroom exercises.

Students who will be severely impacted by the strike and will have difficulty making it to classes, labs, midterms or exams should speak to their professor or lecturer as soon as possible. In the meantime, deans are developing contingency plans in the event of a longer strike.

“We have a creative, supportive academic community at Dal, and I’m confident that our faculty and our students will work together throughout the transit strike,” says Dr. Watters.

Exploring options for employees


As for employees, the university is suggesting that units explore practices for alternative work arrangements where appropriate.

“No matter what your choice of commute, getting to and from work could prove to be challenging,” says Katherine Sheehan, assistant vice-president of human resources. “So if a department or unit can support some of its staff by adjusting or compressing their hours of work, or determining that they can work from home, that can be a significant help towards keeping our campus operations running during a strike.”

While these options won’t work for every employee or department, Ms. Sheehan encourages employees and their managers to discuss what opportunities might exist to ease commuter strain during the strike.

A strike of uncertain length


It’s difficult to know how long a transit strike might last: the 1998 strike went on for a month or so. It’s possible that the university community could be dealing with transportation challenges for a good chunk of the winter term.

That’s why the university is preparing as best it can – it’s even looking at purchasing cots that could be used in residence for students and employees stranded in the event of a major winter storm.

Students affected by the strike say they’re glad the university is doing what it can, though it won’t necessarily alleviate all their worries.

“I liked the options that were presented in the email from the president [last Friday],” explains Stacey Henderson, a fourth-year marine biology student. “And for the most part, carpooling, etc., makes sense, but when you have people coming from all over Bedford, Dartmouth and Lower Sackville, that option doesn’t always work.”

“It’s impressive the university is coming up with alternatives for those who rely on Metro Transit, especially with midterms coming up” says Chloe Malinka, a fourth-year marine biology student. “But is it really the responsibility of the university?”
 
Mr. Burt says that the university is doing what it can, and that while the situation is far from ideal, it’s one that the Dal community will pull through by supporting one another.

“Already, I’m hearing about people offering to carpool their friends and colleagues to campus,” he says. “It’s that Dal community spirit, that drive to help our fellow students and employees, that will make all the difference.”

More on Dalhousie transit strike plans: Transit strike information

Readers Say

What dalhousie is proposing is not enough, or, too much in the wrong direction. It's nice that there are car sharing resources, but the issue that really faces students is missed class time and midterms. Talk to your faculty? What are they going to do? Exempt you from midterms? Until lasting contingencies are put in place, Dalhousie needs a set of rules for staff and students to protect students until transportation to school is possible again. A dartmouth resident with no access to a vehicle cannot make it to school unless they carpool. Wouldn't it be lovey if carpooling actually worked for everyone? You have a geographically diverse student body at Dalhousie! Until students and staff have a chance to adapt to the new set of circumstances, Dalhousie must declare a moratorium on material of extreme importance (midterms, lectures which have no corresponding online content, quizzes, labs, etc.). To selectively disadvantage those students living geographically distant from the school is unfair, and not what we pay 7k a year for.

Yes, carpooling is mighty feelgood, but it doesn't solve the problem students inevitably have to face.
I agree with you David. Also, they propose we carpool, but you need to already own a parking pass to park in the carpool parking lot. So even though I COULD have access to a car and COULD carpool people, I wouldn't have anywhere to park for the day if I did. How is this accommodating us at all?

The worst part is that we are FORCED to pay for the upass, but now if we want parking it needs to come out of our own pockets. Keep in mind that buying a parking pass doesn't even guarantee you'll have parking when you get to the school.
Carpooling is great if it works for you. So will security be our in force ticketing those that have a pass but can't find parking any where? Great time for the University to take away a row of parking spots to give to Dalplex Gold members. Especially since they gave those spots back to the community in September. Will the University ever deal with parking? What about the suggestion of running special buses from Bayers Lake. If the University is truly concerned, how about chartering some buses to come from Bayers Lake?
To have carpooling be basically the only proposed alternative to metro transit is kind of a joke in my opinion. Especially when you consider the problems that the campus already has in regards to parking with people who drive. As it is people who show up later than 8:30am will not find any parking in any of the lots without having to drive around for, in some cases, upwards of an hour before they get a spot. Now how is this going to work when we have an influx of people driving because that is their only option? This is not going to work, there needs to be some kind of protection put in place for students, we are paying an extremely high amount of money for our education just to have it put in jeopardy by a metro transit strike.

Anyone who has ever driven to the school and owned a parking pass before knows how hard it can be to find a spot already. Now that all the people who used to take the bus will be driving to school on top of this it is going to be impossible. I don't know the exact numbers, but I have a feeling that if you were to have every single spot in all the lots of dalhousie taken by a full carpooled car you still wouldn't have enough space to accommodate everyone. I may be wrong, but based on what I have already experienced I believe this is probably the case.
To append to my previous post, there are 17,333 students registered at Dalhousie. Here are the capacity of the residence halls on campus:

Howe Hall: 600 students
Risley Hall: 490 students
Sheriff Hall: 451 students
Eliza Ritchie: 92 students
Gerard Hall: 241 students
O'brien Hall: 115 students

This means that at maximum capacity there will be 1989 students in residence, leaving 15,344 students in need of some kind of transportation to campus not including faculty and staff.

If we assume that every single car in every single spot is occupied by 4 students (which they won't be, there will be cars with single occupants etc. but let's just assume) that means there will need to be 3,836 spots available for use and this is only accounting for students. There is no where near this amount of parking available on campus. Now I know this is assuming that all 15,344 students need to be on campus at the same time, but if you take into account that not all cars are going to be full, and that staff and faculty also need spots this is not a huge leap.

But just to appease anyone who doesn't like these numbers, let's just assume 20% of the non-residence student body is in attendance that means 3068 students are on campus, and also assuming a perfect 4 students per car, that's still 767 spots also still discounting faculty and staff. Even at this rate Dalhousie does not have enough room to accommodate everyone and this is in an absolutely optimal situation.

Now of course these are all rough numbers, but even in the best case scenario things don't look good on the carpooling front, and why should students who can't use this solution have to suffer for it?
Here's a question. Now that a strike is in force will DAL students holding a UPASS be offered a credit to offset their transportation costs? Bad enough being forced to buy a bus pass when you already pay a premium to live within a few hundred feet of the campus. Now the UPASS is, at least for the time being worthless.

Perhaps it's time for the students to ask for a portion of the fees collected from each student to be credit to their students accounts, maybe on a per diem basis.

In my opinion, this is a pretty simple case of paying for a service that's not being provided.
As a staff member with a hunt-and-peck-parking pass, I too am struggling with the contingency plans Dal has in place. The car lot that I regularly use is now a carpool lot for those with at least three Dal community members. Unfortunately, the fact that I carpool everyday with a working spouse and two young children (car seats included) isn't recognized so I'm thrown in to a larger pool of single-riders.
Also, during the strike, why doesn't Dal consider changing some meter parking back into pass-parking (all of those meters located on the South-street side of the Henry Hicks building were free at 8:15 am this morning and looked pretty tempting).

While I'm annoyed by the situation, I'm trying to remember that the transit strike is not just a Dal problem but an HRM problem. I'd like to see how we all could put pressure on city counsel to provide contingency plans for its citizens. The idea of charter buses (SAL) is a good one, but I think the city should be spearheading this and not Halifax employers.
I believe that all regular parking permit holder signed a contract with Dahousie Parking Services that states:

"A Regular Parking Permit gives the holder the right to park in any available non-reserved, non-metered parking space on a specified campus (i.e. either Sexton Campus or Carleton/Studley Campus) between the hours of 7:00 am and 1:30 am."

There is nothing in the contract stating that Dalhousie reserves the right to violate that contract for purposes such as car-pooling etc. Thus Dalhousie is in violation of a contract with all regular permit holders.
Driving isn't the only option available to *some* students and staff. Walking is an option if you are physically able and live within a reasonable distance from Dal. Will it be a hardship? For some, sure. For others, it's merely an inconvenience. I'm sure there are some who are already planning on walking to and from campus, but there are others who live within 15 minutes who are looking for rides to and from that fit into their schedule.

Already, I have responded to two people looking for rides and haven't heard from either. I am willing to help out, but I'm not going to beg people to come with me.

If the strike is long term, perhaps Dal could run a bus from Bayers Lake to Lacewood and Mumford in the morning and back again at the end of the day. People could pay for the service. Maybe they should be doing that anyway?
Topic: Metro Transit Employee Strike
Rationale: Metro Transit quality of life guarantee
It seems ironic that people who paid for (and signed contracts for, as indicated above) Dalhousie parking permits--people who deliberately and for a range of reasons do *not* rely on public transportation to come to work--are being, forcibly, affected by this strike so much. Of course it is a nice thing if people who can do so will give rides to people who didn't buy a parking permit, and people who can reasonably walk should do their part to help, but what gives Dalhousie the right to impose a "solution" that clearly violates the terms of the parking permits? Also, as others have noticed, someone who arrives solo on campus may be dropping off children or spouses or others on their way--what gives Dalhousie the right to tell that person they aren't entitled to use the parking permit that was--as I'm sure we recall--so difficult to get this year, and is hard enough already to use?
In addition to refunding students pro-rated U-PASS fees if the strike continues, Dalhousie should also refund parking permit holders a pro-rated amount of what they paid for the permit. Those permits are not cheap, and with the logic that ProfT provided, it is only fair.
Thanks to everyone who's offered feedback and shared their frustrations over the parking changes; we're listening closely. A transit strike is not 'business as usual' for a university. While we're doing what we can do help, we also want to make sure we're achieving what we set out to.

Our goal with the parking changes, specifically the Hancock lot, is to encourage those who drive to Dal regularly to find more passengers to bring to campus, alleviating traffic congestion and helping those stranded by the strike. We're unfortunately not in a position to offer parking space directly to transit users, due to our limited capacity, but we can support Dal's drivers in helping their fellow students and employees.

We know that these solutions will not be ideal for everyone. For example, we have drivers who bring children into the city, or who carpool with employees from other organizations in Halifax and therefore wouldn't be able to park in the Hancock lot during the morning hours when it's carpool only. Unfortunately, a transit strike presents no perfect solutions - only small steps we can take to try and alleviate some of the strain on our community caused by the difficult circumstances.

How effective were these measures today? About 50 per cent of the Hancock lot was filled today by carpoolers. Our hope is that after the long weekend, if the strike is ongoing, that lot will fill as more members of our community start making connections to carpool. But we'll be monitoring the situation closely: if the carpool lot is not achieving our goals, we'll modify the policy or drop it altogether and return the lot to the way it was before the strike.

My thanks to the Dal community for its patience under the circumstances, and like you, I'm hopeful for a swift resolution to this work stoppage.
Are any of the Administrators willing to put their names on Facebook or Twitter and volunteer to car pool? Maybe they should set an example and "practice what they preach" in their emails to the university community. I'd like to know if any are doing it.
Mr. Burt,

"For example, we have drivers who bring children into the city, or who carpool with employees from other organizations in Halifax and therefore wouldn't be able to park in the Hancock lot during the morning hours when it's carpool only."

So these members of the Dalhousie community who have made these perfectly responsible plans for coming to work and probably lined up for hours (you remember that disaster?) and bought their permits and so on--they are just out of luck that this plan bumps them fromtheir already very limited parking options in favor of other people who didn't buy parking permits? How is that fair to them? You aren't "supporting" Dal's drivers, you are discriminating among them--and in clear violation of the signed contracts for parking permits. This transit strike makes a lot of things difficult, and I'm sure people want to help in whatever ways they can, but it's very odd and presumptuous to take it on yourself to shift bus riders' problems to people who use other methods of transportation with no regard for how difficult it may be for *them* to find alternatives. How does that alleviate the strain on the community? It just highhandedly moves it around. Sure, encourage carpooling and walking and biking and whatever--but don't just change the rules on people who may themselves have no reasonable options.
To Ken Burt - if you are so worried about the situation, do as suggested above and cover the parking meters making them free. How can you ignore this obvious move?
Well what a great response from the administration of our university who have been working on this fabulous plan since last Friday. The only thing they could come up with is to pull together and carpool. Well any other great ideas. I live in Colby (Cole Hr) and it is 18km one way from my house to the campus. I have followed your suggestion and asked every person I know who has a car to try and get even within walking distance of the campus (no luck). Imagine that Dalhousie university is not the only place where people no longer have a way to class or work, it is the entire HRM. I have listed on the myDal classifieds, along with lots of other students with no luck. I have even risked registering on the city site (even more of a waste of time than the Dal one) as traveling with strangers is not the smartest or safest of plans you could expose the student population to. The email made it clear that classes and labs and things will continue as per normal. We are to ask our professors to try and accommodate us but they have not been told to do so by the university. As someone else pointed out we paid a lot of money for tuition and we were forced to purchase the U-pass and thus it was a part of my decision to attend Dalhousie University. Now you are giving us nothing as a viable alternative. I am angry and frustrated at the incompetence of the University to come up with a workable plan, the Metro transit Union for its greed and lack of giving a dam about those of us who depend on the bus to get to class or to our jobs. And the city is just as guilty as the rest in this mess for allowing the union to get to this point, we have one of the worst bus services I have ever used, rude drivers and unreliable schedules and lack of connections. On a good day I spend between 1 1/2 and 2 hrs each way getting to Dal to get an education. I certainly expect some sort of support from such a collection of highly paid and educated people running the university. Do something for us.
I'm also very frustrated with the Hancock lot arrangements. I have several friends who attend SMU and NSCAD (Apparently they too are suffering from the transit strike!) who have no feasible option other than to carpool with me. Am I supposed to refuse to drive these individuals so I can fit the requisite Dal students in my car? While the intent behind these rules is admirable, the implementation is absurd. Providing incentives to people who do carpool is, in my opinion, a better alternative. Alienating the paying customers who buy parking passes is not a good idea.
for those of you forced to buy a upass i feel sorry but it is hard to when you see the ammount of upasses for sale on web sites for 2 0r 3 hundred dollars. as a user of the bus i here regularly students say i sold my pass on kijiji and can get another from the school for 15 bucks
To all of those who are complaining. Just stop and deal with the situation, it's called life. It's not always fair, but how you adapt to it makes you a better person. I don't own a car and I live in Dartmouth, yet I was still able to get to DAL.
Thanks for your compassion during the first day of the strike Dal! I was gifted with a $25 parking ticket for parking in a Dalplex Gold Member spot! So generous of you to take back the parking spots you supposedly gave up in September!
When you are up to your bum in aligators it's hard to plan ahead. The transit strike is a symtom of bad planning and the previous comments do nothing to address the real problem. If Dal's Board of Governors creates a plan to move fifteen thousand students a day a transit strike will be accounted for in those plans.

Join the conversation, but keep it clean, stay on the topic and be brief. Read comments policy.

Characters remaining: 2000

(optional)