Take the taste test

By Melissa Hennigar - January 27, 2011

Gillian Pritchard
Health promotions student Gillian Pritchard is investigating more sustainable options to bottled water on campus. (Nick Pearce Photo)

Unconvinced that tap water really is as good, if not better, than bottled water? Why not take part in a blind tasting that compares bottled water and tap water. Drop by the main lobby of the SUB on Friday, January 28 from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. and taste for yourself.

The event is hosted by the SustainDal water committee, a student group interested in exploring more sustainable sources for water on campus. Eventually, SustainDal would like to see Dalhousie join a growing list of universities that have banned the sale of bottled water on campus.

The SustainDal water committee is led by Gillian Pritchard, a fourth-year health promotions student from Elgin, Ont. Ms. Pritchard was struck by the environmental impact of single use plastic water bottles after attending a Sierra Youth conference in 2008. She would ultimately like to see Dalhousie ban bottled water on campus.

'More sustainable options'

Ms. Pritchard is quick to clarify, “it’s not like we’re going to be policing this policy and ripping plastic water bottles out of people’s hands or anything! We just want to ban the sale of bottled water on campus and provide more sustainable options.”

SustainDal has already made some impressive strides in this direction.

In 2008, the water committee conducted an independent assessment of all 117 water fountains on the three Dalhousie campuses. The results were widely varied, from pristine, clean-tasting water in some buildings, to fountains with water hot enough to brew tea with in others.

SustainDal took its study on campus water fountains to the President’s Advisory Council on Sustainability. As a result, a sub committee was formed to look at campus water issues more closely. Currently, the sub committee is working with Halifax Water to test every fountain and tap on campus to ensure the water is safe to drink. So far, the results have been very encouraging.

The SustainDal water committee also took its results to Facilities Management who they have been working with to install new fountains and clean up existing ones around campus.

“We see it as working to eliminate the amount of plastic bottles in the waste stream of the university. The new fountains we’re installing have a counter on them. Every time a bottle is filled, that is one less plastic bottle and we can keep track of those numbers,” says Lewis MacDonald from Facilities Management.

Starting the conversation

Eliminating bottled water on campus is not as simple as not stocking it in vending machines and food services outlets. Viable alternatives need to be made available to ensure everybody on campus can still access clean drinking water.

“We are working to start the conversation on bottled versus tap water at different levels around campus,” says Ms. Pritchard. “This is already being addressed at an institutional level with the sub committee, but it is a conversation that needs to be happening everywhere.”

Presently, of the 117 fountains on campus, none are located near food service outlets on campus. To this end, SustainDal has partnered with The Blue W, a non-profit organization that supports municipal water. Participating organizations display a Blue W decal which means they will provide fresh, clean tap water without pressure to make a purchase. Currently, there are six locations on campus that display the Blue W decal.

“We’ve got some of the best water in North America, so why not take advantage of it?” says Ms. Pritchard.

LINKS: SustainDal Water Committee | The Blue W initiative

Readers Say

I hope they test the water in the Dunn Building ... It seems worse than any I have ever encountered.
This is a fantastic initiative. I'd love to see Dal ban bottled water sales. But one place that definitely needs improved water fountain supply is the Dalplex! For some reason low water pressure there makes it take ages to fill a half-litre bottle, and there seems to be only one water fountain near where the thirst-inducing fitness classes are held.
I'd love to have more/better/less urinal shaped water fountains, but banning bottled water doesn't make sense to me. Why take away what is probably the healthiest product you can find in our university vending machines? Unless you're going to ban all the other bottled beverages (which are just as environmentally unfriendly as bottled water...more so really), or start selling empty refillable bottles for cheap in the machines, I'd like to keep that consumer option thank you.
While the effort is a great, and the issue important, I disagree with initiative. Like Neil mentioned, bottled water is essentially the healthiest, if not the only healthy option, in the university/SUB vending machines. Instead of buying a bottle of water, a student will buy a bottle of pop. While that may help the DSU fulfil it's pepsi sale quota, it won't help the student.

Also, according to unews.ca article on the issue, the plan is to stop the sale of bottled water THEN get to fixing the issues with the water fountains on campus. That sounds a bit backward to me. I don't know which water fountains have been tested but my experience has been very poor. I've had classes in the LSC, Rowe, McCain, Tupper and the Killam and all have issues. Ex: Foul tasting water, warm temperatures, poor water pressure, inconvenient to downright gross locations (the water fountain behind the LSC Tim Hortons for example is always surrounded by trash and there's only a single water fountain in the entire Rowe). Fix these issues first THEN start talking about banning the bottles.

I believe that banning water bottle sales from campus is not the most effective way of going around this. I, for example, would prefer to see if the DSU could change it's deal with Pepsi Co. and limit sales to those of cans only, which are 100% recyclable. There's a new patent which Pepsi Co. might pick up that leads to a resealable can, which is the biggest disadvantage compared to bottles.

At any rate, good luck with your project. While I disagree with it, your heart and mind is in the right place and are actively doing something about an important issue. For that you have my utmost respect.
The water fountain beside my office has room temp water in it. You could let it run all day and it still doesn't get cold. Replace the old fountains and I wouldn't have a problem refilling my bottle daily. Neil, you are right, all bottles banned or none!
GREAT IDEA! Cold Water bottle refill sites would encourge me to use instead of dirty warm fountains...
They should look at the water "taps" in the new SMU atrium. They are made to fill bottles and have a proximity sensor that turns the water on so that it is delivered to your bottle without contacting anything that need to be cleaned.
I'm also super excited about the Blue W campaign that the water committee helped initiate with food vendors on campus to another option for people wanting to refill their reusable bottle. Look for the Blue W sticker and you can have your water bottle refilled without having to buy anything!

Good work Gill & co.!
<
Where are they?

Also, for those of us who can't consume sugared drinks, water is the only option available in the vending machines when you have to buy - for those days when you forgot your refillable bottle.

If you make clean, cool good tasting water available free, the shift will happen on it's own.
I see many professors in every single class have a brand new water bottle each day. Give EVERY student a water bottle in their ORIENTATION kit, and give every professor a water bottle after hiring, simple. The new students would pay for it in their kit and give the profs complimentary ones to support this initiative!!!!!!

We have perfectly good water in our taps and around campus, it simply is beyond me why people can't get through their head that we are so lucky to have this. Yet, we spend our money on buying plastic bottles that end up in landfills.
If you are going to ban anything why not bottled sugary drinks and leave the only healthy option? Then again 'water' does not provide sponsorship $$$ for the university.
There are no fountains on Sexton Campus. Hopefully SustainDal remembers that we have more than one campus at Dalhousie.
I think it would be great if, within this initiative, they also looked into fountains in residence. Living in res last year I would have -for lack of a better word- killed to have a water fountain. I know there are taps, and most people have fridges, but it's a big hassle to ensure you're drinking enough water in such situations.
I am very glad to hear about this initiative. While I agree with other people that the university should ban all bottled drinks, at least this is a start. I have friends at Memorial University and they recently banned the sale of bottled water on campus; however they first replaced the water fountains with new machines that produced very cold and very refreshing water. These fountains also had a specific tap to fill water bottles. I must say, after seeing these machines and tasting the water, I was more than a bit jealous that Dal did not have a similar initiative.

This sounds like a great start and I look forward to watching this develop!
The new water fountains that have been installed on Dalhousie campus have a water bottle fillers as well as new water dispensers. An example of them can be seen on the ground floor of the the Killam. I agree with what people are saying here, glamourous infrastructure which makes filling up a water bottle slightly easier is apparently necessary. Also providing students with free reusable water bottles at different Dalhousie event such as varsity games, winter carnivals, frosh, etc. are much more of a sustainable initiative than providing them with throw away noise makers.

The big issue here though is banning the sale of bottled water on campus. The sale of bottle bottled water is a global environmental problem. Water is taken out of ecosystems (having negative effects on the flora, fauna and people surrounding the water supply), enclosed in plastic bottles, and shipped far distances to you the consumer to possibly fill up a few times then recycle or through in the trash/litter. That looks like a whole lot of avoidable pollution/energy usage if we just fill up a reusable bottle with local water. Also avoidable habit destruction and negatively impacting human water supplies in other communities. But don't take my word for it there are many ways to research this on your own if you have the time or elective space i recommend taking a first year sustainability course which overviews the the true environmental cost of thought to be everyday actions. If you have less time read blue gold, and if you have even less time check out the movie flow: for the love of water.

I also agree with the removal of coke and pepsi products from the vending machines unless they are 100 percent fruit juices (not from concentrate). But they would probably be heavily marked up (like the water) and I wouldn't buy t anyways.
Personally I've always believed that buying WATER was a waste of money and a really strange practice when you have perfectly good water for free from the tap. Not to mention that botteled water has fewer regulations to make sure its clean then the stuff from the tap. Not only that but what comes from the tap is tested for more things and more times before it leaves the plant then the botteled water. Did you know that botteled water only has to be tested once for bacteria once? and that in only the source water its never tested again nor is it teated for anything else. While tap water one the other hand is cleaned several times, tested before and after every cleaning for beacteria, chlorine and pH levels. Botteled water is tested at the source lake for bacteria put on the truck, botteled then shiped to stores, yeah I really wanna drink that.

Join the conversation, but keep it clean, stay on the topic and be brief. Read comments policy.

Characters remaining: 2000

(optional)