The House Speaker's ruling

Dal News Staff - April 28, 2010

Those interested in Canadian politics had their eyes trained onOttawa as House Speaker Peter Milliken delivered his ruling:Parliament has a right to order the government to produceuncensored documents on the Afghan detainee issue.

The speaker said the federal government breached parliamentaryprivilege with its refusal to produce uncensored documents relatedto the treatment of Afghan detainees and must provide the materialto MPs within two weeks, he said, calling on House leaders,ministers and MPs to find compromise.

“The House and the government have, essentially, anunbroken record of some 140 years of collaboration andaccommodation in cases of this kind,” Mr. Milliken said.“It seems to me that it would be a signal failure for us tosee that record shattered in the third session of the 40thParliament because we lacked the will or the wit to find a solutionto this impasse.”

What do you think about the speaker's ruling? Is it fair andimpartial? Do you believe the House of Commons can come to asolution or do you believe the situation will trigger anelection?

Readers Say

It absolutely is the right decision. If anything, it's a bit soft given the Conservatives have delayed this so long and should have presented the documents long ago. MPs represent us, the people. They all make up the government and must have all of the information available to best do their job. The governing party does not get to change this to protect their own butts and cover up their own shortcomings. Stephen Harper campaigned on transparency and is finally being forced to live up to that - good on the speaker.

However, the dictator is already trying to manipulate the public into thinking the speaker is asking him to break the law - another stall tactic. His rant on protecting civil servants and the troops is a bold faced lie, as every time someone from the military or government speaks up about the detainee issue, he throws them under the bus. This has nothing to do with protecting the troops and everything to do with protecting his own a** and his continued desire to move Canada further right (the direction of fascism) and undermine democracy.
Nice post Billy - fully agree
We are very fortunate to have Peter Milliken as Speaker. He is truly standing up for democracy. Enough of this behaviour Stephen Harper!!!
Absolutely democratic decision. Stephen Harper is trying to shatter the democratic foundations of this great country. For God sake Mr.Harper whatever you do, do it, because unfortunately Canadians have given you a minority mandate, but please do not shatter the norms of this country which are based on human rights and democracy. At least every Canadian is agreed on it. Please respect the Parliament.
Time for a general election.
isn't that milligan fella a dal law school grad, probly from truro too

Join the conversation, but keep it clean, stay on the topic and be brief. Read comments policy.

Characters remaining: 2000

(optional)